|
Hey, appreciate the info. 15 Monitors ! blimey and I thought my cables were a hassle..
I'm running 5400x1920, HD6990, 4xMDP Active (same brand generic) + 1xDVI passive, (Win7x64)
And same problem with HD7970 3xDP-HDMI, 1xDVI-HDMI
And yes you're right about lower resolutions seem to work better, but I think its to do with windows plugnplay monitor settings and hot plug detect.
Since posting I done some more digging and noticed that on my standard desktop one of the monitors was reported as 'generic plug-n-play' in device manager, although through the EDID tool it reported correctly as a Acer T232HL and gave it full HD.
I'm pretty sure the adapters are part of the problem, and I agree with you that I reckon its more reliable with a mix of active and passive adapters - I'm suspicious that the actives don't pass thru the EDID reliably so you end up getting slammed back to lowest resolution of a generic monitor - probably 800x600 whenever theres a glitch.
I've found three interesting things that smell like a smoking gun..
Home theatre guys report blocking pin19 on HDMI cables prevents the hot plug detect function from detecting when a monitor/tv/projector is turned off so fools smart AV amps into staying in hi-res mode when switching between inputs. So same probably applies to DVI/VGA/DP.
Windows seems to do a hot plug detect fairly frequently and anything other than a perfect EDID report pings you back to low res 'generic non-plug n play' settings.. It looks like Hot plug detect might be disabled through USB power saving settings/ not sure on this. It might be that a mix of passives and actives just makes the odd of failure less..
And it all seems to relate back to Windows installing its generic plug n play monitor driver when it doesn't recognise the monitor EDID which results in resolutions of max 800x600 (monitor.inf), I'm not sure how it then cranks this up later.
So I've now seen this same problem across two cards and three setups so its something fundamental in the combination of windows and adapters. not cards or screens.
- you might want to poke in a better default EDID to force everything to a better resolution as a default..
Cheers
|