Page 1 of 1

Eyefinity with different size monitors ?

Posted: 18 Oct 2009, 17:08
by Darthdingo
You have all seen my Eyefinity thread I am sure with my 3 - 24" Dell2408WFP's, they are 1920x1200res each with a grand total now of 5760x1200 resolution.

Was wondering though, for my main/center screen if I can swap in my awesome display I really like my 27" Dell 2707WP, it is also the same res as the other monitors of 1920x1200. I have that one on my upstairs family computer, but how would that look in the center with the two sides the 24" displays ? I like the larger 27" look in WoW, even though same resolution as the other 24", it seems to be a little nicer ?

My main reason is, it seems after a week of Eyefinity gaming, and mainly WoW, that I still look at the center/main display by far the most, and the two sides are just there for glancing at once in awhile, and obviously they really help with immersion factor and really bring the game world to life like never before. But how would that work ? I know size and pixel wise would be funked up, but just curious how that would look or even work ?

Eyefinity with different size monitors ?

Posted: 18 Oct 2009, 17:49
by thatdude90210
I have a Dell 2707 for my center monitor, and a pair of Asus VW266h for side monitors. That's 27" with 25.5" sides, and all 1920 x 1200. And I feel the same, I'm concentrating on the center monitor, the side ones are just peripheral vision. I don't notice the size difference at all. In fact, my compulsiveness is with the color difference of the 2 brands and different type of panels.

With my setup, the difference is ~1/2 inch on top and ~1/2 inch on the bottom of the monitor. And there was no fricking way I was going to get 2 more Dell 27's just for gaming. Just don't have the deskspace, nor did I want to spend the extra one grand difference.

Anyway here are some pics with my setup. I have since done a little bit of calibrating so the color difference is a little better than shown in the pics. The Asus 25.5 tend to look way too blue out of the box when compared to the Dell.




Eyefinity with different size monitors ?

Posted: 18 Oct 2009, 18:46
by Darthdingo
check out my thread here with pictures; I like the 24" + 27" + 24" and will keep it this way :)

http://www.hardforum.com/showthread.php?p=1034776386&posted=1#post1034776386

I see we both have the exact same Dell 27"...I totally love this display, very crisp and sharp image. And to me 27" seems the perfect size for 1920x1200res. Dell now has a newer 27" model, and I looked on e-bay and craigslist, but this 2707 is pretty hard to find anywhere ?

Eyefinity with different size monitors ?

Posted: 18 Oct 2009, 19:34
by Darthdingo
I truly think now that triple surround would look best with a large center display in Landscape, and the sides smaller in Portrait. I bet the best Eyefinity setup if AMD allowed it to work would be 20" + 30" + 20" for a grand total of 4960x1600res. You would still have an awesome center monitor at 30", but flip the 1600x1200res 20" in portrait mode.

But for now I also think 3 - 27" look the best in Eyefinity, I just love the 27" for 1920x1200res, so much better than 24", call me picky I know :p

Eyefinity with different size monitors ?

Posted: 18 Oct 2009, 21:01
by thatdude90210
I would bet that you don't notice the size difference during gaming either. I initially looked at the Dell P2310, because of the displayport, but decided against mixing the P2310's 1920x1080 with the 27's 1920x1200.

The 20" 30" 20" PLP combo would look great, but do many games let you select that kind of resolution?

Eyefinity with different size monitors ?

Posted: 19 Oct 2009, 20:56
by JKeefe
Many games, the well-designed ones in particular, will just use the Windows resolution list as a list of selectable resolutions. So if you have the hardware to set up 4960 x 1600, chances are you can game with the same resolution.

Eyefinity with different size monitors ?

Posted: 19 Oct 2009, 22:39
by Magic Man
Trouble is, 1600x1200 4:3 screens are becomming rare - certainly on this side of the pond...

Eyefinity with different size monitors ?

Posted: 20 Oct 2009, 01:27
by ViciousXUSMC
I have a Dell 2707 for my center monitor, and a pair of Asus VW266h for side monitors. That's 27" with 25.5" sides, and all 1920 x 1200. And I feel the same, I'm concentrating on the center monitor, the side ones are just peripheral vision. I don't notice the size difference at all. In fact, my compulsiveness is with the color difference of the 2 brands and different type of panels.

With my setup, the difference is ~1/2 inch on top and ~1/2 inch on the bottom of the monitor. And there was no fricking way I was going to get 2 more Dell 27's just for gaming. Just don't have the deskspace, nor did I want to spend the extra one grand difference.

Anyway here are some pics with my setup. I have since done a little bit of calibrating so the color difference is a little better than shown in the pics. The Asus 25.5 tend to look way too blue out of the box when compared to the Dell.





That setup looks great to me. I guess I am more picky. I am spending a lot more to take my 2407/2408/2407 dell combo and upgrade it to 3x U2410's because I cant get the colors to match.

As long as I focus on the center screen I can not see the color difference, but I have a habit of looking between the screens a lot when there is not a lot of action going on and I see the color change and it bothered me enough to prompt the excess spending for a perfect setup.

Everybody tells me the U2410 is a wonderfull monitor though and that while I really liked the 2408 I used as a center monitor that its not good for gaming due to its input lag. I never noticed that lag/delay though.

Anybody have the details on the ultra thin bezel 23" samsungs that ATI is recommending to use with eyefinity?

Its going to be too late for me since I just placed my order but I am curious to see them and there price/stat info.

Eyefinity with different size monitors ?

Posted: 20 Oct 2009, 03:04
by davewolfs
Where has ATI made recommendations on monitors to use?

Eyefinity with different size monitors ?

Posted: 20 Oct 2009, 05:10
by thatdude90210
ATI didn't exactly recommendations on monitors. But during the launch of Eyefinity, there were talks that ATI has partnered with some LCD makers who will be launching Eyefinity-friendly LCD's with thin bezels. The Samsung is supposedly due late this year.

Eyefinity with different size monitors ?

Posted: 20 Oct 2009, 05:56
by ViciousXUSMC
It was in a PDF that Dave linked they had 2 monitor recommendations to use for eyefinity, one was the dell2408 I think and the other the "soon to come ultra thin 23" samsung"

I have seen some crazy thin bezel stuff from them so just wondering what this monitor is made up of. If it ends up being a TN panel I wont care, but if it ends up being a nice quality panel that is PVA or IPS and does not break the bank I may have wish I held out on my monitor purchase.

Eyefinity with different size monitors ?

Posted: 24 Oct 2009, 15:24
by Gunja
I've just set up my stuff.
Also different sizes, 27" Dell 2709w and two 26" AOC 619fh
A friend came by to give it a try and i just had to hover around him with a camcorder.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=azz6woMnmcg
I have tried to match the colours on all 3 screens but after spending like 15 min clicking through their osd, i gave up lol

Eyefinity with different size monitors ?

Posted: 25 Oct 2009, 00:48
by thatdude90210
I've just set up my stuff.
Also different sizes, 27" Dell 2709w and two 26" AOC 619fh
A friend came by to give it a try and i just had to hover around him with a camcorder.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=azz6woMnmcg
I have tried to match the colours on all 3 screens but after spending like 15 min clicking through their osd, i gave up lol

Awesome video. Your setup is similar to mine earlier in this thread. Landscape 3x1 is just so perfect for racing games. You can see further into corners, and just have so much more awareness of the surroundings. I'm not much of a simracer but since getting my Eyefinity setup, I couldn't stop playing Race On/Race 07. I guess it brought out my inner-Schumi. :)

Eyefinity with different size monitors ?

Posted: 25 Oct 2009, 01:16
by rbjorn
Nice video, looks great. Just a quick question though. I notice there is no steering wheel visible in the ingame cockpit, how did you remove it? Great when you are using a real wheel yourself.

Eyefinity with different size monitors ?

Posted: 25 Oct 2009, 02:08
by suiken_2mieu
thatdude90210, pretty sweet setup, but that color difference would get to me (it already does, because i have 3 mismatching panels on the 3 of the same model numbers).

Eyefinity with different size monitors ?

Posted: 25 Oct 2009, 02:40
by thatdude90210
Yeah it bugs me as well, much more so than the size difference. It's mostly during replays and such that it bugs me. That's when I usually mess with the color to try to get it better. Luckily during gameplay, I'm mostly focus on the action in the center monitor so the color becomes less an issue.

Eyefinity with different size monitors ?

Posted: 25 Oct 2009, 03:00
by Gunja
I couldn't stop playing Race On/Race 07. I guess it brought out my inner-Schumi. :)

lol ... that's the spirit :)

@rbjorn:
It is a mod.
You'll need toregister to this site to be able to download i think.
Easy to install.

Eyefinity with different size monitors ?

Posted: 26 Oct 2009, 03:44
by TwinIon
I would bet that you don't notice the size difference during gaming either. I initially looked at the Dell P2310, because of the displayport, but decided against mixing the P2310's 1920x1080 with the 27's 1920x1200.


Should eyefinity work mixing those resolutions? I'm trying to decide what third monitor I should get, already having 2x24" 1080p Dells.

I've been considering a 2408WFP for a DP monitor, but I'm not sure how that resolution difference is handled.

Eyefinity with different size monitors ?

Posted: 26 Oct 2009, 05:10
by thatdude90210
Yes, Eyefinity would work. But It goes to the highest supported common resolution of all 3. The resolution of each would be 1920x1080 in that case. That means in your case the picture on the 2408 would be stretched just a touch vertically.

Edit: that's for Eyefinity single large surface mode only. For windows extended or single monitor mode, setting 1920x1200 on the 2408 should be no issue.