Game looks great except cut-scenes are all small or cropped width.
(PLP screenshot with bezel effect)
In-game, DX9 & Aspect Ratio Auto. Quit, SoftTH. In-game select PLP resolution & fullscreen.
If black screen: options were done wrong. Must redo, after resetting graphics (done by deleting file %USERPROFILE%\Rockstar Games\Max Payne 3\graphics.xml )
View guide for general help with the instructions.